Author: Maureen Johnson
Rating: 8.5/10
Genre: Mystery; Young Adult
Just as suddenly as she was pulled out of Ellingham, Stevie is pushed right back in. Though it came at the cost of making a deal with the devil, Edward King, or as Stevie has come to know him, David’s dead dad. But with new evidence surfacing after more than 80 years, Stevie can’t give up the chance to solve the Ellingham case once and for all.
Right off the bat, I can tell you that I enjoyed this book a whole lot more than the first. Partially because I am now familiar with the characters, setting and history, but also due to the basic fact that there is so much more action happening than the first book.
I find our characters likeable and quite distinct. Their different personalities really shined through in this book. These teenage characters also add to the humour and relatability of the books. Furthermore, I was surprised that romance would play such a big part in this series. Disregarding the rocky and kind of nonexistent start, I like their relationship. I find it unique and quite adorable. Simply put, it is very very fun to read.
“Why. Do. People. Do. Stupid. Things."
As for the school itself, while I find it charming, other than specific places connected with the past, I felt that it was under-utilised and could have made for a really extraordinary atmosphere. I think my main issue with the backdrop is the lack of mention of academics when that concept was one of the main reasons I picked up the series.
However, something I really liked is the insinuation that the students are involved somehow in the crime. It really worked to incorporate the setting, which is a school for brilliant children.
In this book, we really delve more into the hidden facts and minuscule details of the Ellingham case. As you read along, you can start to try and piece together what happened. Personally, I reached the realisation at the same time as our main character and it was a great experience.
The dual perspectives were also much more interactive in this book. It was also used in a way that I felt was purposeful and worked to elevate the reading experience (especially when it came to reveals).
On the subject of the mystery. There were a number of reveals in this book, which I found satisfying. Although, I do wish the connections between certain things were more solid. This mystery is very refreshing to read. I think it’s a perfect balance between dark and gruesome (the typical adult mystery) and modern and elementary (a more YA spin). You get the excitement and thrill with none of the gore and disturbing relationships.
As always, I see the potential and room for elaboration and complexity in certain paths that the author has created, and I hope they take the opportunity in the next book. I am anxious to see if all loose ends are tied up and everything comes full circle.
This book focussed a lot on the Ellingham case as opposed to the present mystery, which is completely fine, but I am hoping that the next book, which will probably tackle the current mystery, takes the same winding and exciting road as this one.
Reviewed by: N.G.Rainwater (1st Reading)
Comments