Author: J.K. Rowling
Rating: 9.5/10
Genre: Fantasy; Young Adult
Disclaimer: I am aware of the situation with J.K. Rowling, but I believe in separating the art from the artist. Please respect that this is a review solely on the book.
Between having nightmares that wake him up screaming and trying to defeat a threat with the rest of the world hindering every step, Harry is more burdened than ever as he enters his fifth year at Hogwarts.
This book was different from its predecessors in numerous ways: It does not follow a main arc, it is much slower paced, and it is very centred around the daily lives of our characters. This is because not only were the protagonists unable to play an active role, no considerable action could be taken by any characters due to the situation. Thus, it was really more about exploring the politics in this world as we watch our characters fight an uphill battle one day at a time.
On the whole, I can see why some might find this book not as thrilling as the others, but personally, I loved it. I felt that it really worked to further the parts of the story that are not centred around the conflict or action. Rather, it focused on inner conflicts and struggles and complicated emotions and thoughts. I also really enjoy books like this one, that shows how in the real world, there are many factors other than the ‘bad guys’ that could prevent you from solving problems.
We followed the growth of so many different characters (in particular children and teens) and as they reach adulthood or meet hurdles, we can see how their personalities and quirks translate into what drives them, which are clearly portrayed by their decisions. This really worked to solidify the characters, allowing us to see them as real individuals.
Something I enjoyed immensely about the book was how it explored the school aspect. I know this is true for all the books, but it is especially prominent in this one. It is very fun to read about a character in such a relatable setting. It not only adds to the humour of the books, but has also brought up some of the difficult circumstances students/children might find themselves in. It was refreshing to read because as real and present as these situations are, they are typically seen as quite trivial and thus are not represented in many books.
Furthermore, I really appreciate that the book would explicitly call out a character behaviour (mostly by Hermione, what a gem). This made them acknowledge their flaws and faults, giving them the space to change and thus grow as a person.
This book accurately and realistically portrayed the “If only” dilemma or the “morally gray” concept. The reason I feel this way is because I’m used to the concepts being explored in very dramatic scenarios (in fantasy settings), whereas in Harry Potter, I felt it hit a lot closer to home.
One of the main reasons I love this series is that it explored so many underrepresented concepts so beautifully and realistically.
“Indifference and neglect often do much more damage than outright dislike.”
After having read five of these books, I am in awe of the amount of work that goes into each. The details that comes with each introduction of a branch of the magical world is insane, making the world feel substantial. The magical system has a very strong foundation, the rules are well established, so that everything that happens feels very much grounded in reality.
Not to mention the details that are woven into the plot so as to be used as tools for later, and the items and spells continuously put back into play makes it feel all the more authentic.
The last two chapters of this book absolutely broke me, it was so raw and down to earth. I don't have the words to describe how it made me feel or how much I loved each line.
All of these many components are what make this series like no other; the author weaves the most beautiful and intricate webs and this book in particular, really tugs on your heartstrings.
Reviewed by: N.G.Rainwater (1st Reading)
Comments